COVER STORY
Music & Art Humanities
Digital to the Core
What is studied in the Core Curriculum might change
relatively slowly over the decades, but how students study the
material has changed quite drastically in a few short years. Music
and Art Humanities are prime examples of courses being transformed
through departmental efforts to incorporate technology into
teaching.
Music Humanities sings with online syllabuses, virtual
tapes, Sonic Glossary
Ian
Bent, the Anne Parsons Bender Professor of Music, was an early
proponent of using technology in teaching and encourages other
instructors of Music Hum to take advantage of how the Web can be
woven into the course. In Bent's section, no textbook is required
and students don't have to buy the CD set either, since everything
they need to listen to is accessible through the "virtual tapes"
online.
Bent
starts the semester by handing his students a paper syllabus, then
tells them not to use it since the syllabus posted on the course's
Web page reflects continual changes. And it is not just a list of
what is happening when. Listening assignments and musical examples
play at the click of the mouse, and reading assignments have been
scanned in so they can be printed out or read on-screen.
Take
the week of September 27 to October 2, when the class studied the
Benjamin Britten opera, Turn of the Screw. The online
syllabus takes students to a brief biography of Britten and an
introduction to his music, with links to Web sites about him. The
entire opera is online; students may listen to it in sections or
all at once. Four scenes are detailed with the lyrics as well as
Bent's notes about what requires particular attention. All 213
pages of the Henry James story on which the opera is based appear
with a click, as well as notes on the text. Terms such as "melisma"
are explained by linking to the department's online Sonic
Glossary.
In
addition, the syllabus tells students to see the opera performed
live at Lincoln Center by the New York City Opera and to write a
report about it.
It's
not that students get vastly more material than in the olden days
of reserve reading and cassette tapes, but that the material is
more accessible. The theory is that by making so much material more
readily available, more students will do the reading and the repeat
listening that the course demands. And with students having done
that much preparation before class even convenes, class time may be
devoted to a more in-depth discussion of the subject, rather than
basic instruction.
The
Sonic Glossary (featured in a Fall 1998 CCT story) is an
online study tool developed over the last three years by the Music
Hum staff, the library, the University's Computer Music Center and
the Center for New Media Teaching and Learning. It indexes
approximately 60 terms, from "A niente" to "Word painting."
Clicking on a term brings up a study site where students find an
explanation of the term, complete with pictures, diagrams and
musical examples. The explanation can be read out loud on request.
Those wanting to go more in-depth can sometimes enter "study rooms"
where they can learn and hear more. For example, the discussion of
"madrigal" runs more than a half-hour, is divided into three
sections and includes study rooms as well as listening rooms where
users can hear entire, uninterrupted madrigals rather than
excerpts.
Beyond that, mini-courses are now making their debut, the first
one being "Hearing Major and Minor," which Bent says is an area
where students often have difficulty. The mini-courses take
students through a half-dozen lessons and then quiz them. "It's a
bit like a computer game," Bent says. "You choose what you hear,
and then either your score is tallied or it will ask, 'Do you want
to try that again?'"
Virtual tapes are musical collections custom-created by each
Music Hum instructor that may be accessed anytime online. "They've
become an integral part of Music Humanities," Bent says. In
addition to the virtual tapes, an online reserve collection has
transformed hundreds of performances from CDs and records into a
click & listen collection.
When
Bent wants his class to listen to something that has not yet been
digitized, he takes it to the CCNMTL computer lab in Butler Library
that helps faculty use new technologies in their courses. He feeds
it into the computer himself, then asks the staff to post it on the
course Web site.
One
downside of the virtual tapes is that students can't take them with
them when they graduate; this could be the end of the era of alumni
reminiscing about the Core over an old Music Hum
cassette.
In Art Humanities, digital technology affords a new look at
old masterpieces
The
art history and archaeology department delved into using technology
in teaching long before the creation of the Center for New Media
Teaching and Learning last year. In 1995, the department formed the
Media Center
for Art History, which has since created several digital,
interactive projects for studying art and architecture.
"Our
original mission was to animate the teaching of the Core
Curriculum," says Stephen Murray, chair of the department. "Now
we've expanded that."
|
The
Search Result page of the Art Hum database displays images
discussed in class as thumbnails with descriptive labels. Students
may access larger, high-quality images for study. To enhance the
functionality of the database, multiple images may be called up
simultaneously, allowing students to explore details of complex
compositions or compare a variety of images.
|
|
|
The
first project was to start digitizing the images alumni may
remember buying as a boxed set, and by now more than 1,500 images
may be found in the digital reserve collection. Both in class and
at home, faculty and students can bring up images in a customized
portfolio, explore them by zooming in on details, make notes and
save them.
When
the collection first started to be digitized five years ago,
teaching assistants were shown the paintings online and often
reacted with surprise. They would point to small details and say,
"'We never noticed that before,'" says Robert Cartolano, manager of
academic technologies at Academic Information Systems (AcIS). "It's
more detailed than what they've seen because they can get closer to
the image online than they can looking at the original because it's
behind glass, they can't get too close, can't spend too much
time.."
The
Media Center is working on developing a searchable database that
would scour the collection and bring together images by time
period, location, medium, subject matter and other
criteria.
The
model for that database comes from another departmental project,
"Objects of Desire: The Mediaeval Millennium," which is a database
and Web course material exploring 300 medieval art objects from the
Cloisters and the Metropolitan Museum of Art. With the permission
of the Met, the department took its own digital photographs and
combined them into an online, sometimes-animated tour.
The
next step for the digital reserve collection, once it is
searchable, will be to add biographical information, historical
notes and other contextual material. The site is used both by
students for individual study and by faculty in class via an LCD
projector, although some quality is lost in the projection and
nobody is yet teaching wholly from Web images.
"Digital images on screen are still not as good as slides,"
Murray says. "I predict slides and projectors will have a long,
long life. Digital technology is a supplement."
The
first monument studied in Art Humanities is the Parthenon. In
addition to the images normally used, photographs and lantern
slides dating back to the 1870s have been digitized and put into a
Parthenon Web site.
The
School of Athens project is another Web-based presentation used by
Art Hum sections in smart classrooms
and at home. Part of it, the Raphael Project developed by Professor
David Rosand (the subject of a Spring 1997 CCT cover story),
explores Raphael's frescos in the Vatican. A three-dimensional,
computer-animated video narrated by Rosand takes students through
the space and explains it in words and by graphic dissection.
Period music that is studied in Music Hum plays in the background.
The images are more interactive than just pictures on a computer
screen. By rolling the cursor over an image, for example, the
people represented are identified.
Another multimedia tool being used in Art Humanities is the
Amiens Cathedral CD-ROM. It is a virtual reality tour of the
cathedral composed from 15 hours of video and over 2,000 images
taken on-site by Media Center staff in the summer of 1997. During
the interactive tour, the architecture and many of the objects
within are explained. "The CD.was incredibly informative," wrote
one student on an Art Hum evaluation. "The movies and interactive
demos made it fun to explore. I thought the road noise and birds
chirping were a nice realistic touch, and the choir singing also
really brought out the majesty and grandeur of the building."
Another student wrote, "The CD, more than anything else, has fueled
my desire to physically go to see the cathedral
someday."
Beyond Art Hum, Murray has been spearheading an effort to
create collaborative teaching materials over the Web by bringing
together scholars who teach similar courses at different
universities. Because the faculty members all have specialites,
their contributing material to a site that all can use creates a
more in-depth resource for all.
"I'm
collegial. I like to work with other people," Murray says. "We each
have our specialties that we brief the rest of the faculty on, and
we're all stronger because of it."
That
approach has long been used within a department or through
conferences. Now, by reaching out to other schools and creating an
integrated resource using the Internet, Murray is bringing
collective scholarship to a new level.
Here's how it works. Several professors in the field are
invited to a summer conference. Each makes a presentation on his or
her area of expertise and afterwards submits to Columbia written
and visual materials about it. Columbia's Media Center then
digitizes and integrates the materials onto a Web site that belongs
to and is used by all of the universities whose faculty
contributed. The site is meant to be used as teaching, study and
resource material, but not as a self-contained course.
A
site on the Cathedral of Notre Dame was developed in this way from
a 1998 summer session in Paris. This past June, scholars from the
United States and England met at the University of Granada in Spain
to develop materials for their courses on medieval
architecture.
"Normally at Columbia that course is taught by Stephen Murray -
he covers 1,000 years of history," says Maurice Luker, associate
director of the Media Center. "Now it can be broken down to
specific periods by faculty who have expertise in those
periods."
|